Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

 
©2007-2009 *silentillusion
:iconsilentillusion:

Artist's Comments

:heart: Cover revision! Any critique is highly appreciated!:heart:

[To Page 1]

Amaranth tells the story of Morelle, a society of demons ruled by the vain and powerful Si Komei and his enigmatic, doll-eyed Sih Aret. A somewhat peaceful existence is soon tarnished by unsettling apparitions, vicious monsters, and Aret's increasingly unsettling presence. It becomes apparent that Komei is keeping more than a few secrets, and there are some who will go to any length to uncover them.

You can't hide forever . . .

Critiques


:iconjizaacaso:
When I first saw this pic I thought WOW!
I find it very original and extremely eye-catching. The use of the colors is good and I like the goth-esque style of the whole thing.

I'd suggest a more contrasting color for the title. But I guess the whole pic is attractive at first sight so maybe it won't be really important. Anyway I find the shadows on the hands too dark, specially the right hand of the guy, it took me some time to realize it was actually a hand, but I think that's just because of the shadow.

The girl's face is so nice! I don't really know about Amaranth so maybe I write nonsense, but the guy's face is very feminine, and specially his hands are very feminine. Maybe some bigger, stronger hands would help a lot.

Anyway, lovely coloring, cute design and very well done linework. Keep up the good work! :D
The Artist thought this was FAIR
6 out of 7 deviants thought this was fair.

:iconcrazedms20:
First off, the colors, composition, and subjects are all great.
The designs and lines in the background add depth and an atmosphere, as well as a give a neat quality that really compliments the characters.

All of the problems, and the incredibly few problems, rest with these characters. I love the overall style and appearance, but there are some anatomical issues. The girl's head is a bit too far to the left (ours) of her neck, instead of giving the impression shes leaning a bit, it seems misplaced. The lineart on the man's hand, the one in her hair, is a bit too scratchy and inconsistent with the rest of the piece, and it seems a bit too small.

Despite these two evident problems, I really find this a great cover. It captures lots of personality and is very eye catching.
Great job!
The Artist thought this was FAIR
8 out of 9 deviants thought this was fair.

Thank you for your Critique

You are not logged in.

Comments


love 3 3 joy 1 1 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconhejji:
o__o ... your summary of Amaranth is absolutely perfect.

I feel bad that I'm shaming it with my crappy lack of skillery. :cries:

But still! They both look very good, and I'm very proud of you and your awesome ability to work as you do.

The cover is great, and I feel that Amaranth will not only chronicle your story, but it will also show the improvement of your skill from page to page.

A sort of.. evolving work, whathave you.

--
"I'm gonna kick your ass, and then I'm gonna reenact kicking your ass!" ~ Hank Hill
:iconbunniangel:
this is very beautiful...i love the emotion you put into it and the skill and improvements you have made. I cant wait to read more of your wonderful tale :D

--
† I believe in Jesus Christ my Savior. If you do too and aren\'t scared to admit it then copy and paste this in your signature †

Nurse at *ArtistsHospital
Hidden by Owner
:icontlwelker:
<3 Love the hair and smoothness of it all!
:iconechidnajoe:
That's amazing!

--
The price of freedom is madness
:iconlaretourdemoi:
looks gggggreat! ça c'est bein!

but Aret's face looks a little...pudgy. like she just had her wisdom teeth out and the swelling has gone down some, but not all the way, you know?

but other then that, c'est incroyable!

--
this ain't a trick, baby.
Hidden by Owner
:iconatlantid12:
Beautiful! =)

--
Śnij jak śni się tylko raz, swą maleńką nieskończoność.
:iconelaine-sensei:
Looks awesome. 0_0 Aret's hair is so cool....

--
I really hate my username.

ಥ﹏ಥ
:iconruthenford:
my god. its fucking gorgeous. hot damn :spam:! It looks so professional.

--
WAKEY WAKEY

Details

May 27, 2007
1.2 MB
1.2 MB
921×1500

Statistics

102
174 [who?]
2,800 (1 today)
25 (0 today)

Share

Link
Embed
Thumb

Site Map